Home latest news Courts cannot decide cases based on social media likes, shares & comments...

Courts cannot decide cases based on social media likes, shares & comments – Pres. Ali

0
President Dr Irfaan Ali

Acknowledging the growing influence of social media, where anyone with access to these platforms can publicly express opinions on matters before the courts, President Dr Irfaan Ali has underscored that judicial decisions must remain independent and impartial and must never be influenced by the number of likes, shares, or comments generated by online discussions.

He made the statement on Thursday while addressing the opening ceremony of the 9th biennial conference of the Caribbean Association of Judicial Officers (CAJO) in Georgetown.

“A court cannot decide a case by counting the number of likes, shares, or comments on social media. The law must be determined by evidence, principle, and reason, not by the volume of public sentiment. It is against this changing landscape that we must consider the future development of Caribbean jurisprudence. The law must evolve because the challenges confronting our societies are evolving,” President Ali noted.

According to the Guyanese leader, social media has given virtually anyone with access to online platforms to express opinions on matters before the courts and this presents challenges which must be carefully navigated.

“Greater public attention can promote a better understanding of the judicial process. Of course, our public institutions and citizens have a legitimate interest in understanding how justice is administered. But we must also recognise the dangers. In an environment where information is instantaneous and opinions are often expressed before all the facts are known, public commentary can easily become public judgement. Persons can pronounce on matters without having examined the evidence, understood the applicable law, or appreciated the procedural consideration that may guide a judicial officer,” he outlined.

Against this backdrop, Ali offered key questions that must be considered.

“How do we preserve public confidence in the courts when judgments are sometimes formed before evidence has been fully tested? How do we encourage legitimate scrutiny without permitting misinformation, intimidation, or uninformed commentary to undermine the administration of justice? These are not arguments for shielding the judiciary from criticism. Judicial decisions must remain open to reasoned examination and legitimate public discussion. Indeed, confidence in the judiciary is strengthened when its processes are properly explained. But criticism must be distinguished from intimidation, and public engagement must not become an attempt to influence the outcome of proceedings,” he added.

Public Trust

President Ali also emphasised the importance of safeguarding public trust in the judiciary, especially amid changing concepts globally.
According to Ali, there are three aspects of public trust that are critical: timely and accessible justice, adapting to rapid technological and social changes, and addressing threats.

On the matter of threats, he noted that “a judiciary must have a working understanding and knowledge as to what constitutes a threat to public trust. Because your work is fundamentally based on securing public trust. What are the threats within the country, regionally and internationally, that you should look out for? The threats that will erode public trust. And those are things, I believe, that does not take away from the independence of the judiciary. But it adds to the totality of the judiciary.”

Intelligence Briefing

Additionally, President Ali expressed his belief that the separation of power “cannot be at the expense of separating ideas and separating information”.

In this regard, he advocated for judicial officers having access to certain security intelligence.

“I’ve made this point: the intelligence report on criminal networks and the intelligence report on terrorism in our region must be available to the judiciary, and we have to have a briefing mechanism in which the judiciary has a good understanding as to what exists in our region. Because our Judges must have a clear understanding of the threats our region faces. Now, this may sound simplistic. It may even sound laughable. But I can assure you that this is where many countries are going,” Ali said.

Over 190 delegates from across the Caribbean region are gathered in Georgetown for the three-day conference being held under the theme “Changing Fundamentals of Judging”.

The legal representatives are expected to discuss emerging challenges facing the judiciary and explore opportunities to strengthen the administration of justice throughout the region.

---

Discover more from INews Guyana

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Previous article130-room Staybridge Suites Hotel to be established at Houston
Next articleSophia house destroyed by fire