The Court of Appeal has scheduled November 24 to hear Police Constable Ryan Greene’s challenge to a High Court decision striking out his bail application. Greene has been on remand since October 30, when Magistrate Abigail Gibbs refused to grant him bail on a cybercrime charge involving the alleged unauthorised access to and disclosure of footage from the Government’s Safe Country surveillance system.
On Tuesday, Justice of Appeal Rishi Persaud ordered written submissions ahead of the 13:15h hearing. Greene is represented by Attorney-at-Law Darren Wade, while Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions Diana O’Brien and Attorney Rajendra Jaigobin, alongside King’s Counsel Darshan Ramdhani, are appearing for the Attorney General (AG) and the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Justice Persaud directed Wade to file submissions of no more than five pages, with a separate copy of the High Court ruling, which will not count towards the limit.
The attorneys for the AG and DPP must file their submissions by November 21, also limited to five pages. Wade may submit a reply of up to three pages by November 22. A three-member panel of Justices of Appeal Persaud, Jo-Ann Barlow and Nareshwar Harnanan will hear the appeal. Greene is challenging a November 11 ruling by Justice Zamilla Ally-Seepaul, who struck out a fixed-date application filed on his behalf because it did not invoke the appropriate legal procedure for challenging a Magistrate’s refusal of bail.
In her ruling, Justice Ally-Seepaul examined the avenues available under the Bail Act 2022. Section 17 provides for an appeal to the Full Court against a Magistrate’s decision to grant or refuse bail, while Section 20 allows a challenge by way of judicial review in the High Court. The judge found that the application followed neither route. The procedural objections were raised by King’s Counsel Darshan Ramdhani, representing the DPP.
He argued that Greene’s application had been filed through the wrong legal procedure, since the Bail Act provides for either an appeal to the Full Court or judicial review. He also challenged the naming of the respondents, the failure to properly join the AG and DPP, and the application’s reliance on constitutional provisions without instituting a proper constitutional claim.
Greene’s Attorney, Darren Wade, opposed the objections, maintaining that the High Court had jurisdiction to hear the application and that any procedural defects could be corrected rather than having the matter struck out. He also argued that the court should allow the application to be amended so the substantive question of bail could be considered.
Although the defence relied on Section 32(3), which preserves the High Court’s jurisdiction to grant bail under the Constitution or another law, Justice Ally-Seepaul explained that the provision did not create a separate procedure for a single judge to reconsider a Magistrate’s decision. “The Magistrate’s decision is therefore a judicial decision with legal effect,” Justice Ally-Seepaul said, adding that it could not be ignored simply because the accused claimed entitlement to bail.
Justice Ally-Seepaul also said, “The principle that substance should prevail over form has limits.” She explained that a court could correct defects in form, but was not required to construct a different legal case or substitute a procedure the applicant had not chosen. She also declined to convert the application into judicial review or constitutional proceedings, noting that the defence had maintained it was not pursuing judicial review. The ruling did not determine whether Greene should be granted bail or whether the Magistrate was correct. It addressed only the procedure used to bring the application. The judge ruled that the court ought not to exercise jurisdiction over the application in its present form and struck it out. Greene therefore remains on remand.
Greene, 20, was charged alongside United States (US) sanctioned and indicted Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed under Section 9(2)(b) of the Cybercrime Act over alleged unauthorised access to and disclosure of electronic data from the Government’s Safe Country surveillance system. The charge concerns footage of the October 12 shooting outside the Kitty, Georgetown home of Senior Superintendent Prem Narine, head of the Guyana Police Force’s (GPF) Special Branch Unit.
Police allege Greene downloaded the footage from the Police Command Centre and Mohamed paid him $800,000 for it. The shooting incident allegedly involved Mohamed, his driver and another staff member, all of whom are on bail facing separate charges of unlawful possession of a firearm and ammunition, and attempting to obstruct the course of justice in connection with the incident.
The recording was subsequently played by Mohamed at a press conference, where he presented the footage in support of his account of the October 12 incident. Both men were denied bail by Magistrate Abigail Gibbs on October 30 and remanded until November 24. Police Constable Ashton Chappelle, 24, was later charged with the same offence and remanded.
Discover more from INews Guyana
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

























